Download Continuants: Their Activity, Their Being, and Their Identity by David Wiggins PDF

By David Wiggins

This quantity gathers twelve essays by way of David Wiggins in a space the place his paintings has been really influential. one of the topics taken care of are: endurance of a substance via swap, the idea of a continuant, the common sense of identification, the co-occupation of house via a continuant and its subject, the relation of individual to human organism, the metaphysical proposal of someone, the prestige of artefacts, the relation of the 3-dimensional and 4-dimensional conceptions of fact, and the nomological underpinning of sortal class. From a far better physique of labor the writer has chosen, edited or annotated, and variously shortened or prolonged 11 items. He has extra an advent and one thoroughly new essay, at the philosophy of biology and the function there of the assumption of technique. the gathering starts with an essay postdating his Sameness and Substance Renewed (2001), which amends and upstages his prior presentation of his sortalist notion of id. In next essays and the advent Wiggins examines the contributions to those matters made by means of Heraclitus, Aristotle, Leibniz, Roderick Chisholm, Hilary Putnam, Sydney Shoemaker, Michael Ayers, Saul Kripke, W. V. Quine, David Lewis, Fei Xu, and others.

Show description

Read or Download Continuants: Their Activity, Their Being, and Their Identity PDF

Similar metaphysics books

What, Then, Is Time?

'What is time? ' famous thinker and highbrow historian, Eva Brann mounts an inquiry right into a topic universally agreed to be one of the such a lot ordinary and the main unusual of human reviews.

Phenomenal Qualities: Sense, Perception, and Consciousness

What are exceptional traits, the features of awake reports? How do the outstanding facets of unsleeping reports relate to mind techniques? To what quantity do reports signify the issues round us, or the states of our personal our bodies? Are extraordinary features subjective, belonging to internal psychological episodes of a few sort, and only depending on our brains?

Additional resources for Continuants: Their Activity, Their Being, and Their Identity

Example text

So much for identity, but what about difference? If persistence is excluded beyond the final or crucial addition or subtraction of plank or spar, and the ship we have arbitrarily soon after this event is not determinately identical with what was there before, then is what remains ipso facto determinately and definitely different from what there was before? Again I shall say yes. 39 The remnants of a thing are not the same as the thing itself. ) Are these latter ways of speaking mandatory? I say they are mandatory because I claim that difference is no more a matter of degree than is identity.

And see Chapter 12. IDENTITY , INDIVIDUATION , AND SUBSTANCE  In cases where we had the phusis of a natural substance following its own course, situations of this kind were excluded. For an artefact, however, there is no norm of development that can rule out such happenings. Nor can the whole matter be delegated to a scientist who will delve deeper and deeper into the principle of activity ‘natural’ to a ship or to that sort of ship. There is no such principle. An artefact is its makers’ thing.

A simple continuity criterion of identity requires that this verdict be taken to be a verdict of identity. 20 The notion of identity it invokes cannot subject itself to the requirements we have derived from the logic of the relation. Apply Leibniz’s Law (the Indiscernibility of Identicals, not the 19 That is to say that implicit in these instinctual strivings is the inarticulate grasp of a formal concept. Such a formal concept is a determinable whose determinations are more and more specific kinds of thing.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.69 of 5 – based on 12 votes